I'm having
Butterfinger
21g
sugar · 36g carbs
Have this instead · Reese's
Zero Sugar Miniatures Peanut Butter Cups
−21g sugar
16g
Total carbs
0g
Sugar
13g
Net carbs
Per 3 pieces (26g) · includes 3g fiber
Contains maltitol, which raises blood sugar more than other sweeteners.
Verified from label · 2026-10-03
Chocolate and peanut butter with zero sugar instead of 21g; no zero-sugar crispy Butterfinger exists, so grab the crunchy bar for the crunch.
Buy on Amazon
Also at
Walmart
Target
Walgreens
I'm having this instead
More swaps
Atkins Endulge Crunchalicious Bar
10g total carbs · 1g sugar
Lily's Dark Chocolate Style Peanut Butter Cups
13g total carbs · 1g sugar
You might also like
Milky Way → Atkins
1g sugar · 22g carbs
3 Musketeers → Atkins
1g sugar · 22g carbs
Twizzlers → Twizzlers Zero Sugar
0g sugar · 22g carbs
See all 35: sugar-free candy swaps
Check the package before dosing — recipes change. Store links may be affiliate links. Not medical advice.