Guide
The holiday cookie tin with zero-sugar swaps: the bark, the butter cookies, the cookie dough, the sprinkles and the cocoa
For whoever fills the cookie tin and stirs the cocoa: five swaps that sit on the plate like the usual ones, with each label’s numbers.
5
picks in depth
The tins come down from the top shelf, the butter is softening on the counter, and somebody has already asked about the peppermint bark. Five of the sweet things that fill a December kitchen have swaps you can order this week. Each one goes on the same plate or into the same mug as the usual version.
In the tin
Two that go straight from the box to the plate. ConteKeto reviews the butter cookies on video, and the video plays on the swap page with the creator’s name.
1. For the square of peppermint bark beside the coffee: dark chocolate with peppermint candy through it, wrapped one by one.
ChocZero Dark Chocolate Peppermint Keto Bark
21g
total carbs
0g
sugar
Per 3 pieces (34g), from the brand’s own label, checked 2026-11-20. Source
In place of Ghirardelli Dark Chocolate Peppermint Bark Chocolate Squares, 5.26 oz: 16g sugar, 19g total carbs per 3 squares (35g).
Sweetened with monk fruit extract.
Watch for: Zero sugar on this label still means carbs to list, and nearly all of them are fiber. This is the dark chocolate one. ChocZero’s white peppermint squares carry sugar from milk and are left off this page.
Buy on Amazon
Also at
choczero.com
Amazon shows today’s price when you tap the button.
How to use it: Unwrap a few onto the cookie plate, or break one over a mug of cocoa. The squares are wrapped, so the rest of the box keeps for the next tin.
See both labels side by side →
2. For the blue tin that gets passed around after dinner: crumbly butter cookies sweetened with monk fruit.
ChocZero Danish Butter Cookies (8 oz box)
12g
total carbs
1g
sugar
Per About 4 cookies (28g), from the brand’s own label, checked 2026-11-20. Source
In place of Royal Dansk Assorted Danish Butter Cookies, 12 oz tin: 9g sugar, 22g total carbs per 4 cookies.
Sweetened with monk fruit extract.
Watch for: They are made with almond butter, eggs and milk, so ask about nut allergies before the tin goes around. The label still lists carbs, most of them fiber.
Buy on Amazon
Also at
choczero.com
Amazon shows today’s price when you tap the button.
How to use it: ChocZero sells them in a box and in a blue tin. Buy the tin once, then refill it from the box.
See both labels side by side →
On baking day
3. For the afternoon the kids want to bake: a bag of cookie mix with the chocolate chips already in it.
Lakanto Sugar-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix
10g
total carbs
0g
sugar
Per 1/12 dry mix (16g), from the brand’s own label, checked 2026-11-20. Source
In place of Betty Crocker Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix, 17.5 oz: 12g sugar, 19g total carbs per 2 tbsp mix (24g).
Sweetened with erythritol, monk fruit extract and allulose.
Watch for: The numbers on the bag are for the dry mix, and its serving is smaller than the one on a Betty Crocker bag. It is made with almond flour, and the label lists sugar alcohols, which are part of total carbs.
Buy on Amazon
Also at
lakanto.com
Amazon shows today’s price when you tap the button.
How to use it: Bake a tray alongside the family recipe, so both kinds come out of the oven together and go into the same tin.
See both labels side by side →
4. For the cookies that get decorated at the table: brown chocolate jimmies colored with cocoa.
Good Dee's Sugar Free Chocolate Sprinkles (Midnight Moon)
3g
total carbs
0g
sugar
Per 1 tsp (3.5g), from the brand’s own label, checked 2026-11-20. Source
In place of Betty Crocker Chocolate Sprinkles, 10.5 oz tub: 2g sugar, 3g total carbs per 4g (about 1 tsp).
Sweetened with erythritol and stevia extract.
Watch for: Total carbs on this label match the usual sprinkles, and most of them here are erythritol. The pouch is smaller than a grocery store tub.
Buy on Amazon
Also at
gooddees.com
Amazon shows today’s price when you tap the button.
How to use it: Pour them into a small bowl with a spoon. Good Dee’s shows them in its own video, which plays on the swap page.
See both labels side by side →
In the mug
5. For the mug that goes with the tin: cocoa with the peppermint already in the mix, a seasonal flavor of Lakanto’s drinking chocolate.
Lakanto Sugar-Free Peppermint Drinking Chocolate
12g
total carbs
0g
sugar
Per 2 tbsp (16g), from the brand’s own label, checked 2026-11-20. Source
In place of Starbucks Peppermint Hot Cocoa Mix, 6 ct (6 oz): 17g sugar, 23g total carbs per 1 packet (28g).
Sweetened with monk fruit extract.
Watch for: The label is for the dry mix. Milk brings its own carbs and sugar, so the mug depends on what you stir it into.
Buy on Amazon
Also at
lakanto.com
Amazon shows today’s price when you tap the button.
How to use it: Stir it into hot water or warm milk, and set the bowl of sprinkles beside the mugs.
See both labels side by side →
Send this
The cookie tin card
One swap for each thing on the plate and in the mug, plus the chips and the powdered sugar for baking from scratch. Send it to whoever is baking with you.
•
Peppermint Bark → ChocZero Dark Chocolate Peppermint Keto Bark: 0g sugar, 21g total carbs per 3 pieces (34g). The usual: 16g sugar.
•
Danish Butter Cookies → ChocZero Danish Butter Cookies (8 oz box): 1g sugar, 12g total carbs per About 4 cookies (28g). The usual: 9g sugar.
•
Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix → Lakanto Sugar-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix: 0g sugar, 10g total carbs per 1/12 dry mix (16g). The usual: 12g sugar.
•
Chocolate Sprinkles → Good Dee's Sugar Free Chocolate Sprinkles (Midnight Moon): 0g sugar, 3g total carbs per 1 tsp (3.5g). The usual: 2g sugar.
•
Peppermint Hot Cocoa → Lakanto Sugar-Free Peppermint Drinking Chocolate: 0g sugar, 12g total carbs per 2 tbsp (16g). The usual: 17g sugar.
•
Chocolate chips → Lily's Semi-Sweet Chocolate Style Baking Chips: 0g sugar, 8g total carbs per 1 tbsp (14g). The usual: 8g sugar.
•
Powdered sugar → Lakanto Powdered Monkfruit and Erythritol Sweetener (Powdered Sugar Replacement): 0g sugar, 30g total carbs per 1/4 cup (30g). The usual: 29g sugar.
Numbers from each label, per its own serving.
Numbers come from official labels, per each label's serving. Recipes change, so check the package. Some store links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, zerosugar earns from qualifying purchases. How we check every number