No-sugar pantry swaps: sauces, syrups and baking
64 swaps, most sugar saved first. Every number is checked against the label.
Cornbread mix → Good Dee's
−50g carbs · 6g total carbs
Powdered sugar → Lakanto
−29g sugar · 30g total carbs
Hot Cocoa Mix → Lakanto
−28g sugar · 13g total carbs
Simple Syrup → Jordan's Skinny Mixes
−26g sugar · 0g total carbs
Coconut syrup → Torani
−23g sugar · 0g total carbs
Pancake syrup → Mrs. Butterworth's
−23g sugar · 4g total carbs
Torani vanilla syrup → Torani Sugar Free
−20g sugar · 0g total carbs
Grenadine → Jordan's Skinny Mixes
−20g sugar · 0g total carbs
Torani Toasted Marshmallow Syrup → Torani Sugar Free
−20g sugar · 0g total carbs
Nutella → ChocZero
−20g sugar · 22g total carbs
Cake frosting → Pillsbury
−19g sugar · 17g total carbs
Cake Mix → Pillsbury
−19g sugar · 37g total carbs
Hazelnut Coffee Syrup → Torani
−19g sugar · 0g total carbs
Brownie mix → Pillsbury
−18g sugar · 24g total carbs
Yogurt-covered raisins → Hershey's
−18g sugar · 22g total carbs
Orange chicken sauce → G Hughes
−18g sugar · 1g total carbs
Pudding mix → Jell-O
−18g sugar · 5g total carbs
Caramel apple dip → ChocZero
−18g sugar · 17g total carbs
Jell-O cheesecake pudding → Jell-O Zero Sugar
−18g sugar · 5g total carbs
Honey → ChocZero
−17g sugar · 19g total carbs
Hot fudge sauce → ChocZero
−17g sugar · 16g total carbs
Chocolate frosting → Pillsbury
−17g sugar · 16g total carbs
Yellow cake mix → Duncan Hines
−17g sugar · 21g total carbs
BBQ sauce → Sweet Baby Ray's
−16g sugar · 4g total carbs
Agave nectar → Splenda
−16g sugar · 6g total carbs
Lemon Curd → ChocZero
−13g sugar · 6g total carbs
Pumpkin pie filling → Libby's
−13g sugar · 10g total carbs
Orange Marmalade → Smucker's
−12g sugar · 5g total carbs
Seedless raspberry preserves → Polaner
−12g sugar · 5g total carbs
Seedless Blackberry Jam → Smucker's
−12g sugar · 5g total carbs
Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix → Lakanto
−12g sugar · 10g total carbs
Strawberry jam → Smucker's
−12g sugar · 5g total carbs
Canned baked beans → Bush's
−11g sugar · 26g total carbs
Applesauce cups → Mott's
−11g sugar · 13g total carbs
Poppyseed Dressing → Briannas
−11g sugar · 1g total carbs
Grape jelly → Smucker's
−10g sugar · 5g total carbs
Chocolate chips → Lily's
−8g sugar · 8g total carbs
Raspberry vinaigrette → G Hughes
−7g sugar · 1g total carbs
Chick-fil-A Sauce → G Hughes
−7g sugar · 1g total carbs
Honey mustard dressing → G Hughes
−6g sugar · 0g total carbs
Asian sesame dressing → G Hughes
−6g sugar · 1g total carbs
Marshmallow fluff → ChocZero
−6g sugar · 12g total carbs
Cinnamon Sugar → Lakanto
−6g sugar · 8g total carbs
Bread and butter pickles → Mt. Olive
−5g sugar · 1g total carbs
Coffee Mate Creamer → Coffee mate Zero Sugar
−5g sugar · 1g total carbs
Apple Butter → Good Good
−5g sugar · 5g total carbs
Flavored coffee creamer → Coffee mate
−5g sugar · 1g total carbs
Teriyaki sauce → G Hughes
−3g sugar · 1g total carbs
Sweet relish → Mt. Olive
−3g sugar · 1g total carbs
Prego traditional pasta sauce → Prego No Sugar Added
−3g sugar · 9g total carbs
Nut butter → Justin's
−3g sugar · 5g total carbs
Evaporated Milk → Horizon Organic
−3g sugar · 1g total carbs
Graham cracker crumbs → ChocZero
−3g sugar · 11g total carbs
Ketchup → Heinz
−3g sugar · 1g total carbs
Peanut butter → Smucker's
−2g sugar · 6g total carbs
Cool Whip → Cool Whip Zero Sugar
−2g sugar · 3g total carbs
Pizza sauce → Rao's Homemade
−2g sugar · 3g total carbs
Steak sauce → G Hughes
−2g sugar · 1g total carbs
Rainbow sprinkles → Good Dee's
−2g sugar · 3g total carbs
Chocolate Sprinkles → Good Dee's
−2g sugar · 3g total carbs
Ranch Dressing → Primal Kitchen
−1g sugar · 1g total carbs
Vodka pasta sauce → Rao's Homemade
7g total carbs
Salsa → Herdez
2g total carbs
Alfredo Sauce → Rao's Homemade
2g total carbs
Questions
What are the best no-sugar pantry staples?
The swaps that save the most sugar: Lakanto Powdered Monkfruit and Erythritol Sweetener (Powdered Sugar Replacement) instead of Powdered sugar (0g sugar); Lakanto Sugar Free Drinking Chocolate Mix, Original, 10 oz instead of Hot Cocoa Mix (0g sugar); Jordan's Skinny Mixes Sugar Free Simple Syrup, 25.4 fl oz instead of Simple Syrup (0g sugar); Torani Sugar Free Coconut Syrup instead of Coconut syrup (0g sugar). Every number is from the label.
Which no-sugar pantry staples have the fewest carbs?
Jordan's Skinny Mixes Sugar Free Simple Syrup, 25.4 fl oz (0g total carbs), Torani Sugar Free Coconut Syrup (0g total carbs), Torani Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup (0g total carbs), Jordan's Skinny Mixes Sugar Free Grenadine Syrup (375 mL) (0g total carbs).
Numbers come from official labels. Recipes change, so check the package. Some store links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, zerosugar earns from qualifying purchases.